CALL FOR PAPERS – Page 10 – THE LAWWAY WITH LAWYERS JOURNAL

MALE RAPE VICTIMS: RECOGNIZING INVISIBLE VICTIMS AND THE NEED FOR LEGAL PROTECTION IN INDIA

thelawwaywithlawyers@gmail.com July 22, 2024 0 Comments

THE LAWWAY WITH LAWYERS JOURNAL VOLUME:-13 ISSUE NO:- 13 , JULY 20 , 2024 ISSN (ONLINE):- 2584-1106 Website: www.the lawway with lawyers.com Email: thelawwaywithelawyers@gmail.com Authored By:-Medha Singh MALE RAPE VICTIMS: RECOGNIZING INVISIBLE VICTIMS AND THE NEED FOR LEGAL PROTECTION IN INDIA ABSTRACT: Male rape remains unrecognized in Indian law, despite its prevalence and profound negative impact on victims. While laws protect women from sexual violence, rape, and exploitation, men and boys are not given the same attention. This article challenges stereotypes in both law and society that diminish the recognition of male victims, highlighting the urgent need to protect their dignity and respect against sexual assault and rape. INTRODUCTION: Rape is generally understood as a crime committed by men against women, shaped by a patriarchal society that supports such violence. However, research shows that a significant number of men are victims of rape and sexual violence, although social attitudes exclude them from attention. Male rape is heavily stigmatized in Indian society, especially among heterosexual men, who fear being seen as less masculine or even homosexual if they disclose their assault. This fear discourages many male victims from reporting their experiences, contributing to the high number of reported cases. Deep-seated myths and societal expectations about masculinity further compound these issues, perpetuating a culture of silence and denial surrounding male victimhood. Sexual violence transcends gender, age, and sexual orientation. While extensive research focuses on crimes against women worldwide, there remains a significant gap in awareness of similar crimes against men. Despite the lack of scientific support regarding emotional differences between the sexes, the word ‘man’ itself carries a gender bias, connoting strength, masculine behavior, appearance, and emotional control. This common belief perpetuates a social assumption that separates male and female expression of emotions. In male-dominated 1 Author is a student at University of Petroleum and Energy Studies Dehradun, India societies, it is seen as shameful for men to disclose their experiences of grief, as it is misconstrued as ‘feminine behavior’. According to Roberta Chinsky Matuson. Many people believe that sexual violence is limited to women. There is no doubt that crimes against women are on the rise all over the world, but, indeed, crimes against men are also committed. It is unfair that society pays minimal attention to the crimes against men or the inequalities they face. In India, only a woman can legally be a victim of sexual violence and at the same time, only a man can be legally considered a criminal. In cases where there is a male victim, it is not considered an offense under the Indian Penal Code, 1860. Some countries, such as Denmark, the United Kingdom, and Australia, have proposed and adopted gender-neutral laws. It is shocking that, despite these changes around the world, the Indian judiciary has rejected demands to introduce gender-neutral laws against sexual violence in India. SEXUAL VIOLENCE AGAINST MEN: Gender-based violence transcends age, sexual orientation, and gender, affecting people regardless of these factors. Although the discussion is often focused on violence against women, domestic violence, sexual harassment, and assault, it is important to recognize that men are victims of sexual violence. Despite the advocacy of gender equality, this aspect is often overlooked. Many statutes, such as Section 375 of the Indian Penal Code, define rape based on gender, making men the perpetrators and women the victims. From a legal point of view, it reinforces the old notion that women can only be raped by men, eliminating the possibility of women raping men. Requiring penile penetration as a condition of alleged rape perpetuates this bias by ignoring scenarios in which women can sexually assault men. This is a biased issue because it undermines the principle of equality enshrined in Article 14 of the Constitution of India. This provision guarantees equal protection under the law for all citizens, but the current legislation is not sufficient to address sexual violence against men. The lack of legal protection for male victims perpetuates systemic inequality which is in stark contrast to the protection afforded to children under the Child Sexual Abuse Act, of 2012. Addressing this problem requires a broader understanding of sexual violence than gender stereotypes. This includes changing legal definitions and developing support systems to include all victims, regardless of gender. By acknowledging and correcting this contradiction, society can move closer to true gender equality and justice for victims of gender-based violence. Rape in India is defined in Section 375(3) IPC as the penetration or entry of a foreign body into a woman’s vagina without her consent. This includes sex against a woman’s will, by coercion, by misrepresentation or in a state of intoxication, deception or mental health, or by a person under the age of 18. This definition considers the perpetrator as a man and the victim as a woman, excluding the provision for male victims. As a result, all applicable laws only apply to female victims, which complicates legal inequality and constitutional equality. While the POCSO Act covers sexual offenses against male children, there is no similar provision for adult males. This disparity raises the question of why legal protections differ based on age. The practical reality shown by Insia Dariwala’s research with 1,500 men is that men are significantly stigmatized by sexual harassment due to shame (55%), confusion (50.9%), fear (43%) and guilt (28.7%) Given India’s narrow legal definition of vaginal penetration, incidents of male rape and sexual assault are on the rise, with few legal remedies. For example, the case of a 20-year-old man in Ghazabat who was attacked by a foreign object was classified under Section 377 of the IPC, which shows that the current law is not enough. The armed forces report incidents of sexual violence against men, focusing on wider issues. Currently, only two laws recognize that men can be victims of sexual violence, emphasizing the need for legal reform to comprehensively address this gap. POSCO (Protection of Children from Sexuality) Sexual Harassment of Women in the Workplace Given that men can be victims

“AFFIRMATIVE ACTION AND WELFARE POLICIES: PATHWAYS TO SOCIAL JUSTICE AND INCLUSIVE DEVELOPMENT IN INDIA”

thelawwaywithlawyers@gmail.com July 20, 2024 0 Comments

THE LAWWAY WITH LAWYERS JOURNAL VOLUME:-13 ISSUE NO:- 13 , JULY 27, 2024 ISSN (ONLINE):- 2584-1106 Website: www.the lawway with lawyers.com Email: thelawwaywithelawyers@gmail.com Authored By:- Dr. Ashoka Naika B.G Assistant Professor, Ramaiah College of Law, Bengaluru, Karnataka. “AFFIRMATIVE ACTION AND WELFARE POLICIES: PATHWAYS TO SOCIAL JUSTICE AND INCLUSIVE DEVELOPMENT IN INDIA” ABSTARCT Affirmative action has been the topic of a highly polarized debate, in which it is either demonized as the root of all evil or valorized as the panacea for eliminating discrimination. Sketching out the larger context of and debates around the issue, the abstract analyses the rationale and implementation of affirmative action in India. the rationale for Affirmative Action, The Past and Present of the Affirmative Action Programme in India, Implementation of Affirmative Action Provisions, The Quota Debates, Assessment of the Affirmative Action Programme, quota and Beyond Affirmative action refers to policies and practices designed to address historical and systemic discrimination by promoting equal opportunities for underrepresented groups in areas like education and employment. It aims to create a more inclusive and equitable society by actively working to overcome barriers faced by marginalized communities. Affirmative action and welfare policies in India are constitutionally mandated mechanisms designed to address historical social and economic inequalities faced by marginalized communities, particularly Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, Other Backward Classes, and economically weaker sections. Rooted in Articles 15 and 16 of the Indian Constitution, these policies mainly manifest as reservation quotas in education, employment, and political representation, aiming to promote social justice and inclusive development. Over the decades, affirmative action has significantly enhanced representation and opportunity access, contributing to social mobility and poverty reduction in disadvantaged groups. However, challenges remain, including implementation bottlenecks, administrative inefficiencies, debates over caste-based versus economic criteria, and concerns about meritocracy. Welfare policies complement affirmative action by targeting broader socio-economic upliftment through targeted programs in health, education, and livelihood. In the context of evolving socio-political dynamics and judicial interpretations, these combined frameworks continue to serve as critical pathways for India’s pursuit of equity and social inclusion, while calling for reforms to improve efficacy, fairness, and intersectional inclusivity. This abstract reflects the key themes from recent research and policy analysis concerning affirmative action and welfare in India as of 2025 Key Word: Affirmative action, polarized debate, discrimination, Introduction Social justice is a key concept in the theory and practice of affirmative action. In India, social justice has come to serve as shorthand for affirmative action for disadvantaged groups, mainly lower castes. India is home to one of the oldest and most complex policy regimes of affirmative action. “Affirmative Action and Welfare Policies: Pathways to Social Justice and Inclusive Development in India” encapsulates two crucial approaches aimed at addressing historical social inequalities and promoting equitable growth. Affirmative action in India is primarily rooted in the constitutional commitment to social justice, especially for marginalized communities such as Scheduled Castes (SCs), Scheduled Tribes (STs), and Other Backward Classes (OBCs). It primarily uses reservation policies in education, employment, and political representation to counter caste-based discrimination and to provide equal opportunities. These policies are grounded in Articles 15(4), 16(4), and 46 of the Indian Constitution, aiming not only at non-discrimination but also at proactive empowerment to uplift disadvantaged groups. The approach also includes legal safeguards and welfare programs such as scholarships and social schemes for SC/ST students, reflecting a multidimensional strategy against socio-economic exclusion. Despite progress, disparities persist both within and across marginalized groups, necessitating continual policy evolution. Welfare policies complement affirmative action by focusing broadly on inclusive development. They aim to ensure that economic growth translates into improved social outcomes for all sections of society. Key elements include enhancing access to quality education and healthcare, poverty alleviation, rural and infrastructure development, women empowerment, and financial inclusion. Recent policy frameworks by institutions like NITI Aayog highlight integrated models combining market economy principles with targeted welfare schemes such as PM-JAY (health insurance), PM Awas (housing), and benefits under Jan Dhan Yojana, aligning welfare with inclusive growth objectives.A significant recent judicial view in this domain is the Supreme Court’s 2024 rulings on affirmative action, which emphasized “substantive equality” over mere formal equality. The Court upheld the constitutionality of sub-classifications within the SC/ST categories to address intra-group disparities more precisely, allowing differential benefits based on empirical data. It underscored that equality need not mean treating differently situated individuals identically but must ensure fairness in outcomes. This approach aims at more effective social justice by recognizing systemic barriers within marginalized groups. The Court also prescribed reforms to prevent caste-based segregation in public institutions including prisons and advocated for disability rights with measures to eliminate ableist practices, reinforcing an expansive view of inclusion and social justice. affirmative action and welfare policies in India represent complementary pathways toward social justice and inclusive development—affirmative action addresses historical and structural caste-based disadvantages with a focus on equality of opportunity, while welfare policies seek broad-based improvements in living conditions and capabilities. The recent judicial emphasis on substantive equality reflects an evolving, nuanced understanding of social justice to ensure that benefits reach those most in need within diverse marginalized communities. This holistic approach continues to shape India’s policy and legal landscape toward the vision of an equitable society envisioned by the Constitution. Historical Background of Affirmative Action in India Affirmative action in India has its roots in the colonial period, evolving significantly post-independence to address entrenched social disparities, particularly those linked to caste. During the colonial era, some early forms of affirmative action emerged. For example, Rajarshi Shahu Maharaj of Kolhapur in the early 1900s implemented a novel policy reserving 50% of government jobs in his state for backward communities. Additionally, the 1932 Poona Pact and other political arrangements laid the groundwork for affirmative action by providing limited political representation and protections to marginalized groups, especially Dalits (Scheduled Castes). The Government of India Act, 1935, also included provisions for communal representation in legislative councils with reserved seats for marginalized groups including Dalits and religious minorities. However, these measures during British rule were largely confined to political representation with

EXPLORING THE SOCIO- CULTURAL LANDSCAPE: A COMPREHENSIVE ANALYSIS OF LGBTQ+ IDENTITIES

thelawwaywithlawyers@gmail.com July 10, 2024 0 Comments

THE LAWWAY WITH LAWYERS JOURNAL VOLUME:-13 ISSUE NO:- 13 , JULY 10 , 2024 ISSN (ONLINE):- 2584-1106 Website: www.the lawway with lawyers.com Email: thelawwaywithelawyers@gmail.com AUTHORED BY:- NIHARIKA SINGH BHARATI VIDYAPEETH (DEEMED TO BE) UNIVERSITY, PUNE EXPLORING THE SOCIO- CULTURAL LANDSCAPE: A COMPREHENSIVE ANALYSIS OF LGBTQ+ IDENTITIES ABSTRACT: This research paper aims to provide a comprehensive examination of the LGBTQ+ community, focusing on the socio-cultural dimensions that shape and influence the experiences of individuals within this diverse group. The paper will delve into the historical context of LGBTQ+ rights, explore the challenges faced by LGBTQ+ individuals, analyze the impact of societal attitudes, and discuss the strides made toward inclusivity. Additionally, the paper will highlight the intersections of LGBTQ+ identities with other social categories such as race, ethnicity, and gender, shedding light on the complex and multifaceted nature of LGBTQ+ experiences. Through a thorough review of existing literature, this paper aims to contribute to a deeper understanding of the LGBTQ+ community and foster increased awareness and acceptance. KEYWORDS: LGBTQIA+ , challenges, gender identity, intersectionality, discrimination, societal stigmas. INTRODUCTION: The acronym “LGBTQIA+” represents various facets of our community, with each letter standing for a different gender or sexual identity. The “+” at the end encompasses the many gender identities that are not explicitly included in the acronym. LGBTQ+ includes Lesbians,Gay,Bisexual,Transgender,Queer/Questioning,Intersex,Asexual,+sign at the end meaning anyone who is not explicitly mentioned in the acronym but still identifies as part of the community. Despite being a natural process, variations in human sexuality were considered unnatural problems or diseases until 1990 (BDS, 2010). As a result, the gender and sexual minority (GSM) or LGBT community has faced social stigma, homophobia, transphobia, and exclusion in nearly all social spheres and cultural products. This study aims to explore the current state of their issues and exclusion. A study by the Welcome Trust Centre for Neuroimaging at University College London, using Magnetic Resonance Imaging, suggests that the brains of gay men function similarly to those of straight women, implying that homosexuality is rooted in biology rather than moral choice. Since gender identity is not a choice but a biological compulsion, it is shaped by various factors, including chromosomal sex (internal), hormonal sex (internal), anatomical sex (external), and psychological sex (internal/external), as well as sexual orientations and genders. BACKGROUND: For many years, the term “gay” was used as an umbrella descriptor for the community. In the past, particularly before the 1970s, coming out was not even an option for many people because numerous states had laws criminalizing what they termed “homosexuality” or “sodomy.” Additionally, there was no inclusive acronym for the community, limiting its inclusivity. When an acronym was finally adopted, all versions of it began with “L” for a significant reason. In the early days of the gay rights movement, the lesbian community often felt overlooked or marginalized. This caused considerable division within the community, with lesbians feeling like “second-class” members in the gay rights movement. During the AIDS crisis in the 80s and 90s, thousands of gay men were abandoned by their families after contracting AIDS. In response, the lesbian community united to care for those afflicted, considering them part of their community. To honor their support, the acronym was solidified as “LGB.” However, it took some time to reach the inclusive acronym LGBTQIA+. The goal of LGBTQIA+ is to be as inclusive as possible. The “T” was added in the early 2000s to include transgender individuals, and “LGBT” remained the standard for many years. The “Q” was officially included in 2016, although it had been used by many people for years before that. HISTORICAL CONTEXT AND STIGMA: The LGBTQIA community has endured extensive oppression and discrimination over centuries. Societal attitudes have often manifested in criminalization, pathologization, persecution, and exclusion of non-heteronormative individuals, marked by bias and violence. These historical injustices have left enduring effects, perpetuating stigma and adding to the difficulties the LGBTQIA community faces today. THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL STIGMAS AND STEREOTYPES Societal stigmas and stereotypes significantly affect the lives of LGBTQIA individuals, intensifying their challenges. These negative views foster environments of judgment, prejudice, and discrimination, which manifest in various ways: Self-acceptance and Mental Health: Internalized homophobia, biphobia, and transphobia, spurred by societal stigmas, lead to low self-esteem, anxiety, depression, and other mental health issues. Bullying and Harassment: LGBTQIA individuals often experience bullying and harassment due to societal stigmas, compromising their well-being and safety in many settings. Limited Social Support: Stigmas and stereotypes result in isolation, rejection, and alienation of LGBTQIA individuals, depriving them of support networks essential for personal growth and happiness. Employment Discrimination: Societal stigmas contribute to workplace discrimination against LGBTQIA individuals, leading to higher rates of unemployment. Access to Healthcare: Stigmas and stereotypes create barriers to healthcare access, resulting in inadequate or inappropriate care and obstacles to reproductive and mental health services for LGBTQIA individuals. Cultural Representation: Negative societal stereotypes limit LGBTQIA representation in media, entertainment, and culture, reinforcing biases and denying the community visibility and positive role models. LEGAL AND POLICY CHALLENGES The LGBTQIA community encounters several legal and policy challenges that hinder their pursuit of full equality and protection. Despite advancements in some areas, much remains to be done. Key legal and policy challenges faced by the LGBTQIA community include: Lack of Comprehensive Anti-Discrimination Laws: There is an absence of thorough legislation protecting LGBTQIA individuals from discrimination in employment, housing, education, and healthcare. Inequality in Marriage and Family Rights: While some countries have achieved marriage equality, disparities remain in adoption rights, access to assisted reproductive technologies, and recognition of non-traditional families. Limited Access to Healthcare and Insurance Coverage: Barriers exist for LGBTQIA individuals in obtaining inclusive healthcare and transgender care, with limited insurance coverage and discrimination from healthcare providers exacerbating the issue. Challenges Related to Identity Documents and Official Records: The process for obtaining accurate gender identity documents is often complex, arduous, and costly, posing significant difficulties for transgender and non-binary individuals. Legal Issues for Intersex Individuals: Intersex individuals face specific

NEET AND ITS IMPLICATIONS FOR MEDICAL ADMISSIONS IN INDIA

thelawwaywithlawyers@gmail.com July 5, 2024 0 Comments

THE LAWWAY WITH LAWYERS JOURNAL VOLUME:-13 ISSUE NO:- 13 , JULY 5 , 2024 ISSN (ONLINE):- 2584-1106 Website: www.the lawway with lawyers.com Email: thelawwaywithelawyers@gmail.com Authored by :- Pooja Sulochana V L Student of 2nd Year L.L.B, School of Law, Sathyabama Institute of Science and Technology (Deemed to be University) Chennai – 600119, NEET AND ITS IMPLICATIONS FOR MEDICAL ADMISSIONS IN INDIA ABSTRACT: The National Eligibility-cum-Entrance Test (NEET) was introduced in India to standardize the medical admissions process nationwide. However, since its inception, NEET has been embroiled in controversies, particularly concerning its impact on fairness, accessibility, and the overall integrity of medical education. This paper offers a comprehensive policy analysis of NEET, examining its development, challenges during implementation, and implications for medical admissions in India. NEET was initially designed to ensure a transparent and merit-based selection process for aspiring medical students. Nonetheless, it has faced criticism for widening socioeconomic disparities. Students from rural and economically disadvantaged backgrounds often find it challenging to compete in NEET due to the competitive environment and the need for expensive coaching classes, raising concerns about equal educational opportunities. NEET has been marred by allegations of misconduct, including leaks of exam papers and instances of cheating, which have undermined its credibility. These incidents have also added to the stress and psychological strain experienced by candidates, impacting their mental well-being. This paper assesses NEET’s effectiveness in achieving its goals of transparency and maintaining high standards in medical admissions. It examines the ongoing discourse surrounding NEET and suggests policy reforms to address its shortcomings, aiming to foster a more equitable and inclusive medical education system in India. KEYWORDS Medical education, Medical admissions, Merit-based selection process, Equal educational opportunities, psychological strain, Entrance examination; NEET-PG; NEET-UG; financial barriers INTRODUCTION The implementation of the National Eligibility-cum-Entrance Test (NEET) in 2016 marked a significant change in how medical admissions are conducted in India. Designed to standardize the selection process for undergraduate and postgraduate medical courses nationwide, NEET aimed to replace multiple state and private institution entrance exams with a single, uniform test. Its primary goals were to ensure fairness, meritocracy, and maintain high standards in medical education. NEET has been surrounded by controversy since its inception. Despite its intended benefits, criticisms have emerged regarding its impact on equity, access, and the integrity of medical education. One of the major concerns is the widening socioeconomic disparities exacerbated by NEET. Students from rural areas and economically disadvantaged backgrounds often lack access to adequate preparation resources and face challenges in competing effectively in a highly competitive exam environment. The financial burden associated with coaching classes further amplifies these disparities, raising questions about equal opportunities for all aspiring medical students. NEET has faced allegations of irregularities such as question paper leaks, cheating scandals, and instances of impersonation. These issues have not only damaged the credibility of the exam but have also eroded trust among stakeholders, including students, parents, and the public at large. This paper seeks to conduct a comprehensive policy analysis of NEET, examining its evolution, challenges in implementation, and its implications for medical admissions in India. It will explore the socioeconomic impacts of NEET, evaluate its effectiveness in promoting transparency and merit-based admissions, and contribute to ongoing discussions about its role in shaping medical education policies. Ultimately, the study aims to offer insights and recommendations for policy reforms that can create a more inclusive and equitable medical education system in India. AN OVERVIEW OF EDUCATIONAL INEQUALITY IN INDIA Education has long been recognized as a crucial factor in human development, playing a significant role in improving individuals’ income and living standards by enhancing their skills and self-determination. Moreover, education generates positive externalities that contribute to the overall welfare of society. Increasing participation in schooling is driven by various factors, including indicators of well-being such as health outcomes, fertility rates, nutritional levels, and infant mortality. It is worth noting that the competition among countries, states, and regions for both foreign and domestic investments heavily relies on the proportion of the workforce that has attained at least a basic level of education. Maksymenko and Rabbani (2008) argue that there is a positive relationship between education and economic growth. Similarly, there is a strong correlation between the quality of education and an increase in GDP per capita. Furthermore, improving education is crucial for achieving the Sustainable Development Goals, which emphasize the need for inclusive and high-quality education for all, with a focus on lifelong learning by the year 2030. Based on the Census of India 2011, the younger population aged 0 to 14 years make up approximately 39.5% of the total population, with those aged 0 to 4 years representing 9.7% of the total population. Ensuring equal access to education for this sizable demographic poses a significant challenge for policymakers, especially given that a majority of them come from middle-income and impoverished families. The slow progress in educational achievement has long been a known issue in our country. For example, in 2001, the number of illiterate individuals in India was disproportionately high compared to the overall population at the time of independence. Approximately 350 million of these illiterate individuals were a direct result of ineffective policies and funding practices dating back to the second Five-Year Plan (Mehrotra, 2012). However, by 2004, there was a noticeable increase in school attendance levels, although illiteracy rates remained relatively high (Pieters, 2011). School attendance rates had doubled or tripled in all states except Andhra Pradesh, Rajasthan, Odisha, and Tripura. Furthermore, educational achievement is significantly higher in urban areas of India compared to rural regions (Asadullah and Yalonetzky, 2012). The lack of education and high illiteracy rates among females were particularly concerning, with a 24% gap identified in 2001. Previous research has shown significant improvements in school enrollment, with near-universal enrollment among children aged 6 to 10 years. However, illiteracy rates remain relatively high, especially in rural areas and among female children, potentially due to persistent dropout rates (Chatterjee et al., 2018). In 1968, the Government of India introduced its

DATA PRIVACY AND PROTECTION IN INDIA

thelawwaywithlawyers@gmail.com July 5, 2024 0 Comments

THE LAWWAY WITH LAWYERS JOURNAL VOLUME:-13 ISSUE NO:- 13 , JULY 01 , 2024 ISSN (ONLINE):- 2584-1106 Website: www.the lawway with lawyers.com Email: thelawwaywithelawyers@gmail.com Authored by:- FAJULAE YASMEAN N* BALAJI S** DATA PRIVACY AND PROTECTION IN INDIA * Student, School of Law, Sathyabama Institute of Science and Technology, (Deemed to be University) Chennai, faju24092@gmail.com, 9677208868. **Student, School of Law, Sathyabama Institute of Science and Technology, (Deemed to be University) Chennai, balajisukumar2000@gmail.com, 8939611256. Abstract: In an era of rapid digital transformation, data privacy and protection have emerged as critical contemporary legal issues in India. The exponential increase in internet usage and digital services has led to extensive collection, processing, and storage of personal data by both government and private entities, raising significant concerns about the privacy rights of individuals. The landmark Supreme Court judgement in Justice K.S. Puttaswamy (Retd.) vs Union of India (2017) recognising the right to privacy as a fundamental right under the Indian Constitution has been pivotal in shaping the discourse around data privacy. The Personal Data Protection Bill (PDPB), first introduced in 2019 and currently under review, aims to provide a comprehensive legal framework for protecting personal data. It proposes stringent guidelines for data collection, processing, consent, and storage, and seeks to establish a Data Protection Authority (DPA) to ensure compliance. However, the bill has faced criticism for its broad exemptions granted to the government and the adequacy of safeguards to ensure the independence of the DPA. Further complexities arise from issues such as government surveillance, cross-border data flows, and cybersecurity. The collection of biometric data under the Aadhaar system and the potential misuse of such data highlight the need for robust legal safeguards. Additionally, the dominance of big tech companies in the data economy raises antitrust and competition concerns. Balancing the protection of individual privacy rights with the need for economic growth and innovation is crucial. The ongoing legislative and judicial developments will play a significant role in shaping the future landscape of digital privacy and security in India. Enhancing public awareness and understanding of data privacy rights remains imperative for fostering a more secure digital environment. Keywords: Data Protection, Privacy Rights, Personal Data Protection Bill (PDPB), Cybersecurity, Digital Surveillance Introduction: In today’s digital age, the issue of data privacy and protection has gained unprecedented significance, particularly in a rapidly digitizing country like India. With the proliferation of Internet services and digital technologies, vast amounts of personal data are being collected, processed, and stored by both governmental and private entities. This phenomenon has sparked considerable concern regarding the protection of individual privacy rights, as personal data is increasingly becoming a valuable asset for businesses and a potential tool for government surveillance. The recognition of the right to privacy as a fundamental right by the Supreme Court of India in the landmark 2017 judgment, Justice K.S. Puttaswamy (Retd.) vs Union of India, marked a pivotal moment in India’s legal landscape. This judgment underscored the need for robust legal frameworks to safeguard personal data and set the stage for comprehensive data protection legislation. The Personal Data Protection Bill (PDPB), introduced in 2019 and currently undergoing revisions, represents a significant step towards establishing a comprehensive framework for data protection in India. The bill aims to regulate the collection, processing, and storage of personal data, ensuring that individuals’ privacy rights are protected. However, it has also faced scrutiny over several provisions, including broad exemptions for the government and concerns regarding the independence of the proposed Data Protection Authority (DPA). Beyond legislative measures, India faces challenges related to government surveillance, cross-border data flows, cybersecurity, and the dominance of big tech companies. These issues necessitate a delicate balance between protecting individual privacy and fostering economic innovation and growth. As India navigates these complexities, ongoing legislative and judicial developments will be crucial in shaping the future of digital privacy and security in the country. Enhancing public awareness and understanding of data privacy rights remains essential to fostering a secure digital environment for all citizens. The Personal Data Protection Bill (PDPB): India, boasting the world’s second-largest internet market, is on the cusp of a significant change with the Personal Data Protection Bill (PDPB). This bill aims to establish a framework for data privacy and protection, empowering individuals and regulating how organizations handle personal information. Principles of the PDPB The PDPB recognizes two key aspects: Individual Rights: The PDPB recognizes the right of every individual to control their digital footprint. This principle empowers individuals with a sense of ownership over their data. Here’s a breakdown of the key rights enshrined in the PDPB: Right to Grant or Withhold Consent: Individuals have the power to decide whether or not to allow organizations to process their data. Consent, under the PDPB, must be freely given, based on clear and accessible information about how the data will be used. Pre-checked boxes or vague terms are no longer acceptable. Right to Access and Verify Data: Individuals have the right to request access to the personal data held by organizations about them. This allows individuals to verify the accuracy and completeness of the data, ensuring it reflects reality. Right to Rectification and Erasure (Right to be Forgotten): Individuals have the right to request corrections to any inaccurate or incomplete data. Additionally, under certain conditions, individuals can request the erasure of their data altogether. This “Right to be Forgotten” empowers individuals to reclaim control over their data and potentially limit the impact of past information. Right to Restrict Processing or Object: Individuals have the right to restrict or object to the processing of their data for specific purposes. This allows them to control how their data is used and prevent unwanted processing. Right to Data Portability: Individuals have the right to receive their data in a structured and portable format. This allows them to easily transfer their data between different organizations, promoting greater control and flexibility. By granting these rights, the PDPB empowers individuals to be active participants in the data ecosystem. They can make informed choices about how their

A comprehensive analysis of prisoners’ rights: from punishment to reform.

thelawwaywithlawyers@gmail.com July 5, 2024 0 Comments

THE LAWWAY WITH LAWYERS JOURNAL VOLUME:-13 ISSUE NO:- 13 , JULY 05 , 2024 ISSN (ONLINE):- 2584-1106 Website: www.the lawway with lawyers.com Email: thelawwaywithelawyers@gmail.com Authored by:- Divanshi Meel, OP Jindal Global University A-COMPREHENSIVE-ANALYSIS-OF-PRISONERS-RIGHTS-FROM-PUNISHMENT-TO-REFORM ABSTRACT: This article explores the complex landscape of prisoners’ rights and prison reforms in India. It examines the historical evolution of prisons, highlighting the transition from punitive to more rehabilitative approaches. The article underscores the constitutional guarantees provided by the Indian Constitution, particularly Articles 20, 21, and 22, which extend certain fundamental rights to prisoners. It also discusses statutory safeguards and landmark judicial decisions that have shaped the landscape of prisoners’ rights in India. Despite the constitutional and judicial frameworks in place, the article emphasizes the ongoing need for prison reforms to address issues such as overcrowding, inadequate facilities, and the protection of prisoners’ dignity. It concludes by stressing the importance of a humanistic approach to incarceration, advocating for the integration of human rights into every aspect of prison administration, and calling for sustained efforts and investments to ensure a fair and rehabilitative penal system in India. The primary objective is to analyze the evolution, current status, and future prospects of prisoners’ rights within the Indian penal system, highlighting the constitutional, statutory, and judicial mechanisms that aim to uphold the dignity and human rights of individuals even while they are incarcerated. KEY WORDS: Habeas Corpus: Definition: A legal writ or action that requires a person under arrest to be brought before a judge or into court. The purpose is to ensure that a prisoner can be released from unlawful detention—that is, detention lacking sufficient cause or evidence. The principle of habeas corpus ensures that a prisoner has the right to a fair trial and can challenge the legality of their imprisonment. Relevance: In the context of prisoners’ rights, habeas corpus is a fundamental legal safeguard against arbitrary detention and abuse of power by the state. Due Process: Definition: A legal principle that guarantees fair treatment through the normal judicial system, especially as a citizen’s entitlement. Due process encompasses both procedural aspects (fair and transparent processes) and substantive aspects (fundamental rights protection) to prevent arbitrary denial of life, liberty, or property. Relevance: Ensures that prisoners are afforded fair procedures, including the right to a fair trial, legal representation, and protection against unjust treatment. Fundamental Rights: Definition: Basic human rights enshrined in the Constitution of India that are guaranteed to all citizens. These rights include the right to equality, freedom, against exploitation, to freedom of religion, cultural and educational rights, and the right to constitutional remedies. Relevance: Articles 20, 21, and 22 of the Indian Constitution extend certain fundamental rights to prisoners, ensuring their basic human rights are protected even while incarcerated. Judicial Review: Definition: The power of courts to assess whether a law, policy, or executive action is in compliance with the Constitution. It allows courts to invalidate laws and decisions that are unconstitutional. Relevance: Judicial review plays a critical role in protecting prisoners’ rights by allowing courts to examine and potentially overturn laws and practices that violate constitutional rights and principles. INTRODUCTION: Oscar Wilde’s famous assertion, “Every saint has a past, and every sinner has a future,” resonates deeply with the enduring importance of human dignity and fundamental rights, even within the restrictive environment of prisons. Prisons function as institutions designed to detain individuals accused or convicted of violating laws. Prisoners are those individuals confined within these facilities, isolated from the outside world upon their incarceration. Despite the Constitution of India ensuring fundamental rights to all within its jurisdiction, these rights are not fully accessible to prisoners. This disparity highlights a significant concern: the rights of prisoners. Even within the confines of prison, it is essential not to neglect the principles of human dignity and fundamental rights. Safeguarding these rights is crucial in the ongoing efforts toward prison reform. Fundamentally, prison reforms aim to extend the protections of human rights within the institutional setting, as mandated by the Constitution. Therefore, this presentation endeavors to address the challenges faced by prisoners and advocate for their rights. Prisons are designed to detain individuals charged or convicted of breaking the law. Prisoners are those detained within these facilities. Upon incarceration, individuals lose all connections with the outside world. Although India’s Constitution grants fundamental rights to all within its borders, these rights aren’t fully available to prisoners. This raises prisoner rights concerns. Even in prisons, respect for human dignity and rights must be maintained. Protecting human rights in prisons is vital for reform. Prison reform extends human rights protection inside prisons according to the Constitution.1 HISTORICAL EVOLUTION OF THE PRISONS: The Constitution of India does not explicitly define the rights of prisoners. However, in T.V. Vatheeswaran v. State of Tamil Nadu, the Supreme Court affirmed that Articles 14, 19, and 21 ensure prisoners the right to life, akin to free individuals. The evolution of penal institutions in India, similar to other societies, has been shaped by various social and historical factors. Initially, 1 Anita Yadav, Prisoners’ Rights in India: An Analysis of Legal Framework, 6 INDIAN J.L. & JUST. 131 (2015). prisons were primarily punitive, characterized by harsh and inhumane conditions with little regard for individual rights or well-being. Throughout history, societal attitudes toward punishment and justice have evolved, leading to significant changes in incarceration practices. Post-independence, India began to adopt more humane methods of imprisonment, emphasizing rehabilitation and reformation over mere punishment. Historically, prisoners have been marginalized, rarely considered deserving of welfare or social services. However, with the development of criminology as a field of study, there has been a paradigm shift. The focus has moved away from solely blaming individuals for their criminal behavior to understanding broader social factors influencing such behavior. This shift has led to significant policy changes. Capital punishment, torture, and other severe forms of punishment have gradually been replaced with more humane custodial conditions. Legal and human rights protections for prisoners have been strengthened, and there is now a greater emphasis on retraining,

An Overview Of ‘The Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizenship Act, 2007’

thelawwaywithlawyers@gmail.com June 20, 2024 0 Comments

THE LAWWAY WITH LAWYERS JOURNAL VOLUME:-12 ISSUE NO:- 12, JUNE 20, 2024 ISSN (ONLINE):- 2584-1106 Website: www.the lawway with lawyers.com Authored by:- Guru Prasad Sahu AN-OVERVIEW-OF-‘THE-MAINTENANCE-AND-WELFARE-OF-PARENTS-AND-SENIOR-CITIZENSHIP-ACT-2007 “ Matru Devo Bhava, Pitru Devo Bhava.” Abstract The Senior Citizens Act of 2007 has been a pivotal legislative development in India, offering a comprehensive framework to address the needs of senior citizens. It reaffirms the nation’s commitment to respecting and protecting the rights and dignity of its elderly population. Through provisions for financial support, healthcare access, and social integration, this legislation is a vital step towards ensuring that senior citizens can live their later years with dignity, security, and a sense of belonging in a rapidly changing world. As we delve deeper into the various facets of this Act, we will gain a better understanding of the essential safeguards it provides and how it positively impacts the lives of senior citizens throughout India. The Senior Citizens Act of 2007 emerged as a vital piece of legislation in response to India’s shifting demographic landscape. It aimed to address the unique challenges faced by the growing elderly population. By recognizing the changing family structures, financial insecurity, and social isolation experienced by senior citizens, this Act has played a crucial role in safeguarding their rights, ensuring their well-being, and upholding the traditional values of respect and care for elders in Indian society. Key words — maintenance, welfare, senior citizens, parents, said Act. Introduction In 2007, the Indian government took a significant step towards recognizing and addressing the unique needs and challenges faced by its senior citizens by enacting the Senior Citizens Act. This landmark legislation, officially titled the “Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007,” was enacted with the primary goal of providing legal support and protection to the elderly population of the country. In a nation known for its diverse demographics, where the elderly play a crucial role in shaping its cultural and social fabric, this act represents a vital step in securing their well-being and quality of life. The Senior Citizens Act, 2007, stands as a testament to the government’s commitment to ensuring the dignity, security, and welfare of the elderly. The Act reflects a broader recognition of the unique challenges faced by senior citizens in modern society. India, like many other nations, is witnessing a demographic shift towards an aging population, and this legislation acknowledges the necessity of safeguarding the rights and interests of senior citizens in this evolving social landscape. The key provisions of the Senior Citizens Act are aimed at addressing a range of issues that senior citizens may face. These include financial security, access to healthcare, and protection from neglect, abuse, and violence. The Act has paved the way for the establishment of tribunals to handle disputes and grievances related to the maintenance and welfare of senior citizens, ensuring a prompt and efficient resolution process. One of the most significant aspects of the Senior Citizens Act is the provision for adult children and legal heirs to contribute financially towards the maintenance of their elderly parents. This concept of filial responsibility reflects the traditional values of respect and care for elders that have long been a part of Indian culture. The Act empowers senior citizens to seek maintenance from their children or legal heirs if they are unable to support themselves, ensuring their financial well-being in their twilight years. Furthermore, the Act encourages the establishment of old-age homes and multi-service centers that cater to the various needs of senior citizens, including healthcare, social engagement, and recreational activities. By doing so, it not only addresses physical and financial challenges but also combats the issue of social isolation, promoting emotional and mental well-being among the elderly. Background & Historical Context: Demographic Trends in India: Aging Population: India, like many countries, has been experiencing a significant shift in its demographic makeup over the past few This shift is characterized by a rapidly aging population. Increased life expectancy, reduced fertility rates, and improved healthcare have contributed to a larger elderly population. As a result, India’s senior citizen demographic has been steadily growing. Urbanization and Migration: Another demographic trend is the migration of younger generations to urban areas in search of better employment opportunities and education. This migration often leaves senior citizens behind in rural or semi-urban areas, where they may face economic and social challenges. Changing Family Structures: Traditionally, Indian society was known for its strong family bonds and intergenerational living arrangements. However, these dynamics have been Nuclear families have become more common, and elders are increasingly left to fend for themselves. This transformation has left many senior citizens vulnerable, without a reliable support system. Pre-Act Scenario: Before the enactment of the Senior Citizens Act in 2007, senior citizens in India faced numerous challenges, which can be summarized as follows: Lack of Legal Recourse: Prior to the Act, there was no specific legal framework that addressed the issues of maintenance and welfare for senior This left elderly individuals with limited legal recourse in cases of neglect or financial dependency. Financial Insecurity: Many senior citizens struggled financially due to a lack of adequate retirement benefits and pension This financial insecurity often resulted in dependence on their children or legal heirs for basic needs. Neglect and Abuse: With changing family structures and values, some elderly individuals faced neglect and abuse from their own Cases of senior citizens being mistreated or abandoned were not uncommon. Limited Access to Healthcare: Access to quality healthcare is crucial for senior citizens, but many struggled to afford the medical care they The absence of a comprehensive healthcare support system added to their challenges. Social Isolation: The transformation of family structures and migration of younger generations often led to social isolation for senior Loneliness and a lack of social engagement took a toll on their mental and emotional well-being. The Senior Citizens Act of 2007: Recognizing the pressing need to address these issues, the Indian government enacted the Senior Citizens Act in

The Media Deterrent Effect

thelawwaywithlawyers@gmail.com June 10, 2024 0 Comments

THE LAWWAY WITH LAWYERS JOURNAL VOLUME:-12 ISSUE NO:- 12 , JUNE 10 , 2024 ISSN (ONLINE):- 2584-1106 Website: www.the lawway with lawyers.com Email: thelawwaywithelawyers@gmail.com Authored by:- Shruti Chandran The-Media-Deterrent-Effect Abstract In today’s interconnected world, the media is a fundamental part of society, offering numerous benefits such as providing news, promoting transparency, enhancing cultural exchange, and driving social change. This article examines the diverse functions of the media, its influence on public opinion, legal proceedings, and societal development. Additionally, it explores the “media deterrent effect,” where media coverage of wrongdoings discourages similar actions by others. High-profile cases in India, such as the Jessica Lal murder, the Nirbhaya gang rape, and the Aarushi Talwar-Hemraj murders, highlight the media’s significant impact. The article also underscores the principles of judicial independence in India, emphasizing the need for the judiciary to remain unbiased despite media pressure. In responding to media pressures, it becomes essential for the judiciary to uphold its independence and ensure fair trials without external influence. While the media plays a vital role in highlighting societal issues and injustices, there are concerns regarding sensationalism and potential interference in legal proceedings. Striking a balance between press freedom and the right to a fair trial is crucial for maintaining justice and public confidence in the legal system. The judiciary must remain impartial, applying the law objectively despite media narratives, to uphold both the reality and perception of justice. Ethical guidelines and media oversight are instrumental in mitigating sensationalism and promoting responsible and equitable media coverage. Keywords High profile case, judicial independence, Democracy. Introduction In the modern world, the media is a pillar of democracy, essential for disseminating information and fostering public dialogue. Its role extends beyond reporting news; the media acts as a catalyst for social change, cultural exchange, and economic development. In addition, the media functions as a watchdog, monitoring government actions and holding officials accountable, which is essential for preventing power abuses. Through investigative journalism, it reveals corruption, human rights abuses, and other misconduct, prompting necessary reforms and keeping the public informed and engaged. This article explores the various roles of the media, the concept of the media deterrent effect, and the influence of media coverage on legal cases in India. It also discusses the importance of maintaining judicial independence in the face of media scrutiny, ensuring that justice is administered fairly and impartially. Additionally, it explores the delicate balance between press freedom and the protection of individual rights, highlighting the media’s duty to report accurately and ethically. By exploring these facets, we gain a deeper insight into the media’s societal impact and the essential role of responsible journalism in supporting the principles of democracy and justice. The Media Deterrent Effect The “media deterrent effect” refers to the phenomenon where extensive media coverage of individuals being penalized for wrongful actions deters others from committing similar acts. This concept extends beyond crime to health, environmental, and social behaviors. The effectiveness of this deterrent depends on media presentation, public interest, and individual perceptions. Overexposure or sensationalism can sometimes lead to desensitization, diminishing the deterrent effect. Thus, while the media can influence behavior, it must balance its approach to maintain effectiveness. Media coverage can be a powerful tool for reinforcing societal norms and discouraging undesirable actions. For example, extensive reporting on the repercussions of drunk driving, tax evasion, or environmental offenses can foster a culture of accountability and discourage similar misconduct. In the realm of public health, media campaigns that emphasize the risks of smoking or the advantages of vaccinations can significantly shape individual behaviors and health outcomes. However, the media deterrent effect faces several challenges. Media bias and the selective presentation of information can distort public perception, potentially misaligning it with reality. Additionally, a constant stream of negative news can lead to apathy or helplessness among audiences, diminishing the intended deterrent impact. The media deterrent effect is particularly significant in legal contexts. High-profile cases often attract substantial media attention, and the publicization of legal outcomes can serve as a deterrent to potential offenders. Nonetheless, this can result in the problem of trial by media, where public opinion influences judicial proceedings, potentially compromising the fairness of trials. For the media deterrent effect to be effective, media outlets must take a responsible and balanced approach. Ethical journalism that prioritizes accurate and thorough reporting is essential. Providing context and avoiding sensationalism can help maintain public trust and ensure the deterrent effect remains positive and sustainable. As the media landscape evolves with the growth of digital platforms and social media, the principles of responsible journalism become even more critical in shaping public behavior and societal norms. High-Profile Cases in India Several notable legal cases in India have demonstrated the media’s significant influence, The media plays several vital roles in modern society. It keeps the public informed about local and global events, which is crucial for maintaining an informed citizenry in democratic nations. By covering government actions, policies, and political events, the media fosters transparency and holds officials accountable. It also promotes cultural exchange by enhancing understanding and appreciation of different cultures, thereby contributing to global harmony and cooperation. Social media platforms enable worldwide communication and networking, strengthening social connections. Additionally, the media supports economic development by providing advertising platforms for businesses, which create jobs and stimulate economic growth. Furthermore, the media is essential in raising awareness about social issues, health concerns, and environmental challenges, mobilizing public support for positive change. Jessica Lal Murder Case: The 1999 Jessica Lal murder case exposed significant weaknesses in India’s legal system. Intense media coverage triggered nationwide protests and forced authorities to re-examine the case, resulting in the conviction of the perpetrators. This highlighted the media’s power to influence justice and advocate for judicial reform, emphasizing the importance of transparency and public confidence in legal proceedings. The case became a turning point in Indian legal history, sparking widespread discussion and reforms aimed at preventing similar injustices. Nirbhaya Gang Rape Case: The 2012 brutal

Strategies for Enhancing Women’s Representation in the Lok Sabha: Analyzing the Impact and Implementation of the Women’s Reservation Bill.

thelawwaywithlawyers@gmail.com May 30, 2024 0 Comments

THE LAWWAY WITH LAWYERS JOURNAL VOLUME:-11 ISSUE NO:- 11 , MAY 30 , 2024 ISSN (ONLINE):- 2584-1106 Website: www.the lawway with lawyers.com Email: thelawwaywithelawyers@gmail.com Authored by:- Sakkcham Singh Parmaar STRATEGIES-FOR-ENHANCING-WOMENS-REPRESENTATION-IN-THE-LOK-SABHA-ANALYZING-THE-IMPACT-AND-IMPLEMENTATION-OF-THE-WOMENS-RESERVATION-BILL Abstract:- The underrepresentation of women in India’s Lok Sabha, the lower house of the Indian parliament, has been a longstanding issue that has drawn significant attention from scholars and policymakers alike. The Women’s Reservation Bill, which proposes to reserve one-third of the seats in the Lok Sabha and state legislative assemblies for women, has been a subject of intense debate and discussion since its introduction in the late 1990s. The existing literature on the topic provides valuable insights into the impact and implementation of the Women’s Reservation Bill. The study found that the reservation of local government seats for women in India led to a reduction in crimes against women, demonstrating the potential impact of increasing women’s political representation. Similarly, the analysis by the authors of the ‘Gender Audit for Gender Mainstreaming of Coastal and Marine Fishing Community of India’ highlights the low representation of fisherwomen in the legislative assemblies, emphasizing the need for more targeted efforts to ensure the inclusion of marginalized groups in the political process. At the same time, the normative-empirical study on the political rights of women in the Indonesian constitution suggests that a shift from the quota system to a system of reserved legislative seats may be more effective in increasing women. Therefore, different studies show the impact and implementation of the Women’s Reservation Bill, while at the same time, few studies show the growing area of concern where the bill needs to come into effect and work as a voice for women. History:- The advocacy for political reservation for women in India started in the early years of the 20th century with notable figures such as Begum Shah Nawaz and Sarojini Naidu championing political equity in 1931. It was brought to light by the National Action Committee on the Status of Women in 1971 that women were not adequately represented in political positions. This prompted the 1988 National Perspective Plan for Women which proposed having seats reserved for women at every level of governance consequently resulting in the 73rd and 74th Constitutional Amendments. To reserve one-third of seats in the Lok Sabha and State Legislative Assemblies for women is the purpose of the Women’s Reservation Bill introduced in 1996. Despite many attempts to make it into law, the Bill has received significant opposition as different administrations showed interest in passing this landmark legislation but could not do so because of political conflicts and fears over the effects on the existing reservations for Other Backward Classes (OBCs). NDA Government (1998-2004): Many tries were made by the government to pass the bill but there was internal resistance and lack of agreement among leaders. UPA Government (2004-2014): Despite repeated trials, the government faced resistance from critical allies, leading to its failure in the House of People after having been successfully moved through the Rajya Sabha back in 2010. The advocacy for 2023 Hunger Strikes demands such protests as K. Kavitha’s hunger strike that is meant to urge for the passage of the Bill, underscoring continuous political splits and controversies over its necessity. Especially, their way of achieving The Women’s Reservation Bill vividly illustrates the intricacies of the political scene in India as unflagging endeavours are frustrated by political, social, and cultural factors of importance. Women’s Reservation Act, 2023:- India has passed a law that guarantees women one-third of all their Lok Sabha seats; their State Legislative Assemblies’ seats; or seats reserved for people from Scheduled Castes (SC) or Scheduled Tribes (ST); or any other such body where we have these scheduled categories represented like National Capital Territory of Delhi’s Legislative Assembly which also have some quotas regarding these groups as mentioned above here under certain circumstances. By an amendment to the Constitution (Article 330 & c) these classes were recognized as castes by the government hence adding complexity to federal Indian politics such that these women must be elected/appointed into 1/3 of their houses without regard for social norms whatsoever. The reservation will start when demographic figures are released after conducting a census following the introduction of this law and it will continue until fifteen years unless parliament decides to extend it. After every delimitation exercise, there will be a law made by the parliament on how the seats for women move around regarding this specific matter. Presently, with regards to the Lok Sabha number 17 that will be in session between 2019 and 2024, only 15% of elected representatives are females and when it comes to state houses this figure drops even lower up to 9% on average. The Indian Constitution does not allow women reservation in the public sector explicitly. In contrast, Paragraph 16(2) prohibits sexual orientation-based discrimination in the workplace. Therefore, as the Supreme Court observed in the Indra Sawhney case of 1992, women will only be granted lateral rather than vertical reservation. Reservation for women is a form of reservation where women are also provided with an equal opportunity just the way it happens in horizontal reservations. This type of reservation cuts across vertical categories specifically for women, disabled, transgender, and veterans. Each vertical category is treated differently as far as applying the horizontal quota is concerned. For instance, if women account for 50% of the horizontal quota, then in each vertical quota category, half of the elected representatives must be women. Women’s Participation in different sectors and Women’s Job Quota in different States:- Women’s employment reservations have greatly advanced in some Indian states. In 2006, a 30% horizontal reservation for women who are domiciled in the state was ordered by the Uttarakhand government. Even though it was briefly lifted in 2022 by the High Court, the Supreme Court allowed its implementation after which an ordinance was issued reaffirming the government’s intention towards this particular policy in 2023. This is a case of vertical reservations that are available to women from any

THE CRISIS OF CRIMES AGAINST ANIMALS AND LEGAL REMEDIES

thelawwaywithlawyers@gmail.com May 25, 2024 0 Comments

THE LAWWAY WITH LAWYERS JOURNAL VOLUME:-11 ISSUE NO:- 11 , MAY 25 , 2024 ISSN (ONLINE):- 2584-1106 Website: www.the lawway with lawyers.com Email: thelawwaywithelawyers@gmail.com Authored by:- Yogita Sharma THE-CRISIS-OF-CRIMES-AGAINST-ANIMALS-AND-LEGAL-REMEDIES ABSTRACT Animals play a significant role in the stability of the environment, ecosystem, and human lives. Without them, our existence is not possible. In India, from ancient times animals have been an integral part of its economy and ecology. In their protection lies our survival. Yet the animal laws and their rights remained a largely neglected field with few people even aware of it. As a result, animals in our country have suffered enormous violence, abuse and cruelty. In the country where animals are treated as gods in scriptures cases of animal abandonment are quite visible. For the ethical treatment of animals, it is necessary to make animal laws both familiar and accessible. The situations of medical care for animals and veterinarians are under development leading to exploitations of the non-human world for self benefit whether in cosmetic industries or barefaced street abuse. No doubt development is changing nations drastically it doesn’t mean humans have the right to misuse and take advantage of nature haphazardly. We’re destroying and degrading the habitats of other species to grow our world. By not fulfilling their duty human dig a pit for themselves. The way of implementing the schemes and crimes against animal rights calls for debates on the subject and reformulation of weak penal provisions. On the negative side, the Courts have sometimes shown a liberal approach towards violations of the rights of animals. The people must have an important role in understanding the significance of ecology and all living beings. The basic freedoms of animals to access nature must be granted to them. The research analyzes the overview of animal suffering in Indian society with the legal remedies provided to them. Additionally, there are a few recommendations for the reader to ensure the fair treatment of the non-human world. Keywords: Crimes against animals, Schemes for animal welfare, Animal rights and new legal developments. INTRODUCTION Although human is also considered as animals but what differs the human race from animals is its wisdom. It is only humans who can domesticate any other animals and use them to fulfil their needs. Everyone knows animals can contribute to human welfare in many ways, including companionship, mental health, rescues, food, therapy and aids for people with disabilities. For the rural world, sharing space with wildlife is second nature. But as development gets fast-tracked the delicate, value-based balance of man and nature is tilting.1 High demands of humanleadto exploitations of [Not only nature but also animals, birds, mammals] flora and fauna. Such situations venture violent conflicts which are increasingly common features of the developing trophiesyet dangerous flagship species, face resistance from people whose lives, livelihoods and worldviews are impacted. The reportsays coexistence with wild animals in India is “reaching the threshold of tolerance”.2 Distinctive conflicts causing many offences towards animals. Wild animals often roam outside the protectedareas and domestic animals are often abandoned by their owner. Now the question arise Does animals responsible for the conflicts or species with brains seizing their inhabitants? How growing population of humans lead to the destruction of animal inhabitants? And at the end, animals are held responsible for this. The question we most of time encountered in a general knowledge quiz is to name the official animal or bird of a state or union territory or your country. We all are familiar with the bird, animal and tree that represent our region. But have you ever questioned that why these symbols represents us? Most of us never try to find the relevant reason behind labelling few animals as State or National bird or animal. In an interview with the Down to earth, author and the person behind the Wildlife Protection Act, 1972, M K Ranjith Singh Jhala shared that he and his team members issued the concept to state government in the 1970s. The main symbols was to give the endemic species special attention, administering a sense of pride in them.3 While it may seem like a great way to increase awareness and encourage conservations, having the tag of ‘State Animal’ has worked for some species while for many others, it has become an irrelevant piece of trivia. The international union for conservation of nature (IUCN) Red list of endangered species include 157190 species, with 44016 of threatened with extinction. 4It’s all because of human activities, their requirements and urge to fulfil them on any costs. Every year these list of endangered species or vulnerable species reaching new highs. [I] REQUIREMENTS OF ANIMALS TO HUMAN WORLD As a human we need animals to survive in this planet earth. Animals are important to human wellbeing and key to human development. According to IFAW’s newest report A guide book for incorporating conservation and animal welfare into development planning, highlights some of important ways in which animals effect human wellbeing and why they are essential in sustainable developments. Over a million species are in danger of going extinct if we don’t changes the ways in which we interact with nature. Income inequality, look of potable water and pandemics like COVID-19 has been linked to wildlife exploitation and habitat degradation. Have we ever thought why animals are important?5 Majorly due to – Healthy ecosystems and robust wildlife protections support secure livelihoods. Pastoralism supports sustainable development. Animal welfare and conservations support human health. Food security and livelihoods are linked to good animal welfare and conservations practices. Clean water, sustainable infrastructure and climate resilience demand animal conscious development. The exclusion of animals from national and international policies affects people. The contribution of animals to human welfare can’t be neglected. Animals improve the welfare of humans in many ways from ancient time by providing food or being carrier, companion or improving mental health, facilitating rescue during natural disaster. In Indian subcontinent animals were treated as gods still exploitation of animals existed with development of human world.