THE LAWWAY WITH LAWYERS JOURNAL
VOLUME:-10 ISSUE NO:- 10 ,April 20, 2024
ISSN (ONLINE):- 2584-1106
Website: www.the lawway with lawyers.com
Email: thelawwaywithelawyers@gmail.com
DIGITAL-DIVIDES-A-COMPARATIVE-ANALYSIS-OF-CYBERCRIMES-AGAINST-WOMEN-IN-RUSSIA-AND-INDIA
Dr. Pallavi Singh
Assistant Professor of Law
Central University of South Bihar
Аnastasia Ochkina
Assistant of the Civil Law Department
Saratov State Law Academy
Abstract
The cyber divides that exacerbate risks for women in both Russia and India are the main topic of this paper’s comparative study of cybercrimes against women. The spread of technology in recent years has created previously unheard-of opportunities as well as new targets for abuse. Using a range of sources such as scholarly investigations, official documents, and case studies, this study looks at how the different judicial systems and socio-cultural settings in these two nations affect the experiences of female victims. It looks at the types and frequency of cybercrimes against women, such as financial fraud, revenge porn, cyberstalking, and online harassment. The efficacy of current laws and law enforcement tactics in combating these crimes and offering assistance to victims is also examined in this article. This study intends to provide insights for policy suggestions and actions targeted at reducing digital gaps and improving women’s security in the digital sphere by shedding light on the parallels and differences between Russia and India.
Keywords: Cybercrime, Cyberlaws, India, Russia, Technology.
Introduction
Technology has completely changed how civilizations connect, communicate, and operate in the modern digital age. Although this change has opened up previously unheard-of possibilities for advancement and connection, it has also revealed a darker side marked by cybercrimes, especially against weaker demographics like women. The delicate relationship between gender dynamics and the changing digital world is highlighted by cybercrimes against women, which pose a serious global concern. In this regard, comprehending the subtleties of cybervictimization becomes crucial, especially in countries with distinct sociocultural settings like India and Russia.
The purpose of this article is to compare cybercrimes against women in Russia and India, two nations with very different technology infrastructures, legal systems, and sociocultural backgrounds. We want to explore the similarities, differences, and underlying causes of the digital inequalities that exacerbate women’s vulnerability by looking at the experiences of female victims in these different settings. With its history of governmental monitoring and technological competence, Russia offers a complex environment for studying cyber victimisation. While the quick growth of internet connection has made everything more connected than before, it has also created an environment that is ideal for cyber exploitation. Russian women are subject to a wide range of online risks, such as financial fraud, revenge porn, harassment, and cyberstalking. Furthermore, there are substantial obstacles because of ingrained patriarchal attitudes and the lack of comprehensive legal measures.
However, India is a rapidly developing digital economy characterised by wide socioeconomic gaps. Internet penetration has expanded as a result of the nation’s quick digitalization initiatives, especially among metropolitan people. But this digital transformation has also made women more vulnerable to online abuse, financial frauds, and cyberbullying, among other forms of cybervictimization. The intricate legal structure and varied cultural milieu of India make it more difficult to address cybercrimes against women, calling for specialised interventions and strong enforcement measures. This study intends to add to a nuanced knowledge of cyber victimisation and improve evidence-based preventative and intervention efforts by contrasting the experiences of women in Russia and India. This article aims to advocate for improved safeguards and empowerment for women worldwide by shedding light on the digital divisions that sustain gender inequality in cyberspace via thorough research and analysis.
A Comparative Overview of Cybercrimes Against Women
Cybercrimes against women comprise a variety of malevolent actions carried out via digital channels that specifically target women according to their gender. These crimes can take many different forms, including as harassment, exploitation, and fraud. They are frequently motivated by power disparities and gender-based discrimination. These cybercrimes seriously jeopardise women’s safety, wellbeing, and socioeconomic stability in both Russia and India.
One of the most common types of cybercrimes against women is harassment, which includes sharing sexually explicit information without permission, cyberbullying, and online stalking. In digital areas such as messaging apps, online forums, and social media platforms, harassment of
women is a common occurrence for women in Russia and India. Such harassment can have severe psychological repercussions for victims, including stress, worry, and terror. Vulnerable women are frequently the focus of cyberbullying, which preys on their trust and takes use of their weaknesses for illicit financial gain or other reasons. This covers things like trafficking, sextortion, and internet grooming. There are differences in the prevalence of exploitation between Russia and India that can be attributed to differences in socioeconomic status, cultural standards, and the efficiency of law enforcement.
Fraudulent schemes also present serious threats to women in both nations, such as identity theft, phishing scams, and online financial fraud. Cybercriminals take advantage of women’s gullibility and trust to trick them into sending money under false pretences or divulging private information. Such fraud has an impact that goes beyond monetary losses; it may lead to social isolation, mental pain, and reputational harm. Russia and India have different patterns and tendencies when it comes to the frequency and occurrence of cybercrimes against women. Although Russia has a highly developed technology infrastructure and a high rate of internet access, it also has issues with state
sponsored monitoring and a lack of strict implementation of laws against cybercrime. On the other hand, although the digital environment in India is expanding quickly, a sizeable portion of the populace does not have access to cybersecurity or basic computer literacy. In spite of these variations, the effect on victims is quite consistent. Both nations suffer greatly from the psychological pain, strained social ties, and threatened economic stability caused by cybercrimes against women. To tackle these issues, legislators, law enforcement agencies, IT corporations, and civil society organisations must work together to improve cybercrime victim care systems, prosecution strategies, and preventative measures.
Factors Involved with Cybervictimization
A complex interaction between technological, legal, and sociocultural elements shapes cyber victimisation of women. In order to avoid and lessen cybercrimes against women, it is essential to comprehend these factors.
Gender inequality and patriarchal structures: Gender inequality and patriarchal norms are major factors contributing to the increase of cyber victimisation of women in Russia and India. Pernicious preconceptions and power disparities are frequently reinforced by deeply ingrained cultural views, normalising gender-based violence in both online and offline contexts. Because of deeply ingrained cultural ideas that place a premium on male dominance and control over women’s bodies
and behaviours, women may be more vulnerable to online harassment, exploitation, and discrimination.
Technical Aspects: Inequalities in digital literacy and technological access make women more susceptible to cybervictimization. Women from lower socioeconomic origins, rural locations, and marginalised populations in Russia and India frequently do not have enough access to the internet and other technology tools. Moreover, women are more vulnerable to cyber abuse and fraud due to their lower knowledge of online privacy and security precautions. These vulnerabilities are exacerbated by gendered patterns of technology usage and online behaviour, which provide particular difficulties for women in properly navigating digital settings.
Legal Aspects: The Efficiency of the Law and Its Enforcement The frequency and repercussions of cybercrimes against women are greatly influenced by the efficiency of regulatory frameworks and enforcement systems. Although cybercrimes are covered by legislation in both Russia and India, their enforcement may be uneven or insufficient, giving offenders a free pass. Women who have been cyber victimized may be deterred from seeking justice or help if there are insufficient legal safeguards or reporting obstacles. Moreover, attempts to address cross-border cybercrimes targeting women are hampered by deficiencies in international collaboration and coordination, which frequently leave victims without redress.
Multifaceted strategies that tackle the underlying causes of gender inequality, expand access to digital resources and education, fortify legal safeguards, and bolster enforcement mechanisms are needed to address these problems. Policymakers, civil society organisations, and tech corporations may collaborate to build safer online environments for women in Russia, India, and other countries by tackling socio-cultural, technological, and legal impediments.
Responses as well as Interventions
A comprehensive strategy combining government initiatives, civil society activities, and the use of technical solutions is needed to address cybercrimes against women. Stakeholders may collaborate to stop cyber victimisation and help individuals who are impacted by it by making use of these tools.
Governmental Efforts: Programmes and Policies to Combat Cybercrimes The governments of Russia and India play a pivotal role in mitigating cybercrimes against women by formulating and executing regulations and initiatives. This involves passing laws that
particularly target internet offences against women, such online exploitation and harassment. Governments can also create specialised law enforcement teams that are equipped to deal with cybercrimes and assist victims. To make sure that current laws and regulations are still applicable and efficient in combating emerging cyberthreats, regular evaluation and revision are important.
Civil Society Initiatives: Advocacy Campaigns and Support Services Organisations from the civil society are essential in offering advocacy and support to victims of cybercrimes against women. These groups provide a variety of services, such as counselling, crisis hotlines, legal support, and safe havens for victims in need of protection. Advocacy campaigns seek to change laws to better protect women online, dispel social norms that support gender-based violence against women, and increase public awareness of cybervictimization. Working together, civil society organisations and government agencies may guarantee victims receive comprehensive care and improve the efficacy of initiatives.
Technology’s Role: Techniques and Instruments to Strengthen Cybersecurity Women may be shielded from online risks and cybersecurity can be improved with the help of technology. To protect personal data and stop illegal access, this involves creating secure communication channels, encryption technologies, and anti-phishing software. Programmes that promote digital literacy may teach women safe online behaviour and provide them the tools they need to identify and neutralise online threats. Technology businesses may also take action against online harassment and abuse by putting in place measures like content moderation guidelines and reporting systems that allow abusive behaviour to be quickly addressed.
A coordinated response to cybercrimes against women may be established by stakeholders through the combination of government measures, technology solutions, and civil society activities, with the ultimate objective being the creation of safer and more inclusive online environments. To adequately handle the complex issues raised by cyber victimisation and guarantee the safety and empowerment of women in the digital age, coordination and collaboration amongst several sectors are crucial.
Perceptions and Awareness
The way that the public views and is aware of cybercrimes against women greatly influences how these issues are addressed and how successful prevention efforts are. Addressing cyber victimisation requires an understanding of attitudes towards cybercrimes, knowledge of hazards and preventative measures, and tactics for teaching and empowering women.
Recognising Public Opinion: Views Regarding Cybercrimes The way that the public views cybercrimes against women can have a big influence on how these concerns are acknowledged and prioritised in society. Opinions on cyberbullying, exploitation, and deception may differ according to cultural standards, gender norms, and victim-blaming beliefs. It might be useful to look at how the public views cybercrimes in order to find myths, prejudices, and obstacles to getting assistance or reporting events. Establishing a supportive atmosphere for those impacted by cyber victimisation necessitates addressing negative attitudes and promoting empathy towards victims.
Awareness Levels: Understanding of Dangers and Countermeasures For preventative and intervention efforts to be successful, women’s awareness of the dangers of cybervictimization and the protective measures that are available is essential. It’s possible that many women are unaware of typical cyberthreats like identity theft, phishing schemes, and online grooming, which leaves them open to abuse. Women may be empowered to effectively traverse digital environments and reduce dangers by learning about privacy settings, reporting systems, and online safety practices. To provide inclusive and accessible support systems, it is imperative that women from varied socio-economic backgrounds and age groups raise their level of knowledge.
Empowerment and Education: Developing Women’s Resilience Education is essential for enabling women to identify and effectively address cyberthreats. Including cybersecurity and digital literacy in school curriculum and community initiatives can provide women the information and abilities they need to stay safe online. Women’s involvement and leadership in the digital economy may also be increased by supporting digital empowerment programmes including mentoring programmes, coding workshops, and entrepreneurship courses. These activities help lessen women’s susceptibility to cybervictimization and foster a culture of digital citizenship and empowerment by enhancing their resilience and self-efficacy.
In order to create safer and more inclusive online spaces for women in Russia, India, and other countries, stakeholders may strive to address attitudes and awareness gaps, promote education and empowerment, and provide a supportive atmosphere for victims. To prevent and mitigate cybercrimes against women and advance gender equality in the digital sphere, cooperation between government agencies, civil society organisations, educational institutions, and technology businesses is crucial.
Challenges and Opportunities
In order to effectively combat cybercrimes against women, it is necessary to navigate a number of obstacles while taking advantage of chances to improve assistance, intervention, and prevention. Safer online environments for women depend on recognising and resolving these issues as well as seizing joint venture and innovation possibilities.
Breaking Through Obstacles: Handling Legal Vapour and Enforcing Issues Legal frameworks frequently lag behind the quick advancement of technology, which leads to gaps in the law and difficulties enforcing enforcement when it comes to preventing cybercrimes against women. Legislative loopholes, a lack of funding, and uneven enforcement make it difficult to prosecute offenders and deliver victims’ justice in both Russia and India. To overcome these obstacles, changes must be made to the legislation pertaining to cybercrime, the capabilities of law enforcement, and the communication between governmental and non-governmental organisations. To further guarantee that the rights of women who have been cyber victimized are respected and safeguarded, it is imperative to advance legal literacy and provide them with access to the court system.
Overcoming the Digital Gap: Methods for Improving Access and Reading Inequalities in digital literacy and technological access make women more susceptible to cybervictimization. Comprehensive policies that address socioeconomic disparities, encourage digital inclusion, and guarantee fair access to technology and education are needed to close the digital gap. This entails making investments in the construction of infrastructure, increasing internet access in underserved and rural areas, and incorporating digital literacy initiatives into both official and informal education systems. In order to lower their risk of becoming cyber victims and increase their involvement in the digital economy, women must be equipped with the knowledge, abilities, and tools necessary to traverse digital environments safely.
Cooperation and collaboration: global alliances and information exchange Since cybercrimes against women across national boundaries, it is critical that nations work together to solve these problems. For the purpose of jointly combating cybercrimes worldwide, partnerships may be established between governments, law enforcement agencies, civil society organisations, and technology corporations. These partnerships can promote information sharing and capacity building. Platforms for exchanging best practices, organising reactions, and promoting legislative changes to improve cybersecurity and defend women’s rights in the digital era are offered by international organisations and forums. Through the promotion of collaboration
and cooperation among global stakeholders, a united front against cyber victimisation may be formed, hence amplifying their effect.
Through the resolution of obstacles including legislative loopholes, digital disparities, and enforcement gaps, along with the utilisation of cooperation and innovation possibilities, stakeholders may strive towards establishing online environments that are safer and more inclusive for women in Russia, India, and other parts of the world. To effectively address cybercrimes against women and advance gender equality in the digital sphere, multi-sectoral methods, persistent investment, and ongoing communication are needed.
Conclusion
To sum up, the comparative examination of cybercrimes against women in Russia and India has shed light on a number of facets of this widespread problem, including similarities, differences, and areas that should be addressed. The results highlighted the ways that technology differences, long-standing gender inequality, and weak legal systems contribute to cyber victimisation in both nations. Women are more vulnerable to cyber exploitation due to issues including insufficient laws, barriers to enforcement, and social views about gender-based violence. Nonetheless, cooperative initiatives across governmental bodies, non-profits, and digital enterprises present encouraging paths for improving support, intervention, and preventive systems. Prioritising legislative changes, making investments in digital infrastructure and education, and promoting global collaboration are some of the recommendations. Research on longitudinal studies, qualitative research, and ongoing campaigns to increase awareness, advance digital literacy, and empower women in the digital age should be the main priorities going ahead. Stakeholders may endeavour to provide a more secure and welcoming virtual space free from harassment and exploitation for women by putting these suggestions into practice.
References
- Patel, Aarav. “The Legal Framework for Addressing Cybercrimes Against Women in India.” Indian Journal of Law and Technology 10, no. 1 (2020): 88-105.
- Sharma, Nisha. “Bridging the Digital Divide: Strategies for Enhancing Digital Literacy Among Women in India.” Journal of Digital Education and Empowerment 5, no. 4 (2018): 512-529.
- Radha Ranjan, Behind the mask: Exploring the world of deepfakes, Conscientia Legalis (2024) Available at https://www.researchgate.net/publication/379986947 Legalishttps://conscientialegalis.wordpress.com/2024/04/20/behind-the-mask-exploring the-world-of-deepfakes/
- Radha Ranjan, Jivantika Gulati, Deep fake porn: duplicity and dystopia, Lex Assisto Publication. First Edition, Volume 1, (2023) Available at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/377977062
- Radha Ranjan, Dr. Pallavi Singh, Cyber crime against women: A view, Jyotirveda Prasthanam Journal, Edition 12, Issue 1 Available at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/377466357
- Gupta, Priya. “Digital Divides: Exploring Cybercrimes Against Women in India.” International Journal of Gender and Technology 7, no. 3 (2022): 112-129. • Radha Ranjan, Dr. Pallavi Singh, Cyber Crime Against Women in Cyber Space: A Critical Analysis of Indian Legislations, Kanpur Philosophers Journal Volume X, Issue I(A), March 2023 Available at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/379181975
- Smith, John. “Cyber Victimization and Gender Inequality: A Comparative Analysis of Russia and India.” Journal of Cybersecurity Studies 14, no. 2 (2023): 245-267. • Radha Ranjan, Jivantika Gulati, The Sexual Harassment against Women in Cyber Space: Concept, Reality and the Law, Kashmir Journal of Legal Studies, Volume 10, No 1 (2023) Available at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/378488323
- Petrov, Dmitry. “Gendered Perspectives on Cyber Victimization in Russia.” Russian Gender Studies Journal 18, no. 2 (2019): 301-320.
- Radha Ranjan, Unveiling the futurebattlefield: Navigating thechallenges of 21st-century technologyand cyber warfare, Legalonus Journal (2023) Available at: https://legalonus.com/unveiling-the-future-battlefield-navigating-the-challenges-of-21st century-technology-and-cyber-warfare/ and https://www.researchgate.net/publication/375697750
- Ranjan, Radha. “Right to privacy.” International Journalof Legal Research & Governance Law Mantra, UGC Approved Journal 4, no.1 (2018) Available at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/371607585
- Ivanova, Maria. “Cybercrimes Against Women in Russia: Challenges and Responses.” Russian Law Review 26, no. 4 (2021): 567-589.